Skip to main content

The role of meat in the human diet: evolutionary aspects and nutritional value

Leroy, F., Smith, N., Adegbola T Adesogan, Beal, T., Iannotti, L., Moughan, P. and Mann, N. (2023). The role of meat in the human diet: evolutionary aspects and nutritional value. Animal Frontiers, [online] 13(2), pp.11–18. doi:https://doi.org/10.1093/af/vfac093.

"indicating evolutionary reliance on, and compatibility with, substantial meat intake"

This paper has quite a lot of good information that I could quote and probably not a lot for me to actually write up so your best bet is to just go and read the paper. Here are some highlights. They state that is it likely that there is a contribution between the pushback on meat and the increase in disease seen around the world, this is because the removal of meat leave a broad spectrum of nutrients out of the diet. 

Not only is meat the best source for protein but it contains most of the global supply of vitamin B12 and is a good supply for "other B vitamins, retinol, long-chain omega-3 fatty acids, several minerals in bioavailable forms (e.g., iron and zinc), and a variety of bioactive compounds with health-improving potential (e.g., taurine, creatine, and carnosine)."

Not mentioned in the article but recent studies have lined taurine with an increase in longevity suggesting that many could benefit from supplementing with it, one could argue that those on animal based diets might not need to? 

They argue that throughout evolution there is clear evidence that humans have evolved to thrive on meat and that has been " cherished by human communities as a nutritious and highly symbolic food" They also show the below diagram, please do go to the article and I will happily remove the image if anyone has any issues with me presenting it!



Some of the evidence on human evolution and a meat based diet is then discussed. They discuss our stomach and guts stating that "With a simple stomach, relatively elongated small intestine, and reduced cecum and colon, the human gut is suggestive of reliance on a high-quality diet in which meat was predominant. "

The importance of protein is also discussed. Protein in Plants is not as bioavailable so you have to consume a lot extra, in a gut not evolved to process it, in order to get adequate amounts. There are also, especially when included organ meat, a lot of nutrients that are significantly more bioavailable from animal sources than from any other source. 

Comments

Popular posts from this blog

Bridging the Gap: Lessons from Marius Bakken and the Norwegian Method

As a self-confessed "obsessive researcher" of running science, I eagerly awaited my copy of The Norwegian Method Applied by Dr Marius Bakken. My goal was to see how it complemented the Norwegian Singles approach by James Copeland (Sirpoc) that I’ve been implementing earlier this year. While both authors advocate for a similar threshold-driven strategy, Bakken’s deep dive into the physiological nuances has given me several "lightbulb moments." Here is how I am refining my own training—and my coaching—based on these new insights. 1. The Power of the 'Cut-Back' Week Bakken reinforces the necessity of recovery, but he also suggests that a "week" doesn't have to be seven days. I’ve realised I’ve been training quite close to my limit lately. To stay on the right side of the injury line, I am introducing structured cut-back periods. Instead of a full calendar week of rest, I’m experimenting with a "mini-taper" approach: Wednesday: Reduced...

The Science of Slow: Decoding the MAF Method and Aerobic Health

 In the modern era of "high-intensity interval training" (HIIT) and "no pain, no gain" fitness culture, the suggestion to slow down is often met with scepticism. However, if we look at the gold standard of exercise physiology, the evidence is clear: to run fast, we must first master the art of running slowly. Today, I want to take a deep dive into a seminal paper that forms a cornerstone of my coaching philosophy: "Maximum Aerobic Function: Method for Determining Aerobic Fitness in the Resistance Era" by Dr Phil Maffetone and Prof. Paul Laursen (2016).                                         The "Resistance Era": Why We Are Over-Training The authors begin by identifying a modern crisis in fitness. We live in an "over-fat" and "over-stressed" society, yet our approach to exercise is often to add more stress. Maffetone and Laursen argue that many athletes are stuck in a cycle of "anae...

My Progress and Goals for 2025

I was hoping to do vlogs but it appears I am not very good at that, also it is usually good to have some exciting content to post... and well with me it is mostly the same each week. I ate meat, I ran slowly (except for parkrun) and I was building on being consistent.  And really being consistent is my goal for this year. I ideally would like to stay happy and healthy whilst getting some personal bests along the way, I don't know if I will do it but if I love the process it doesn't really matter.  So what are my goals, both outcome and process?  Run 3000 miles - ideally run, but if I get ill or injured then cross training might have to count.  Consistently strength train  Consistently work on my mental health and training.  Stick to a carnivore diet Continue to learn  Break my 5k PB (17:08)  and ideally run 16:43. The latter because parkrun stopwatch bingo says I only haven't finished in a time with 43 on the end!  Run a half marathon PB (1:2...